Mama Carolla's Old Italian Restaurant

Add to Favorites

CLOSED NOW

Tomorrow: 5:00 pm - 9:30 pm

(317) 259-9412Call Visit WebsiteVisit Website Map & DirectionsDirections1031 E 54th StIndianapolis, IN 46220 Write a ReviewWrite Review

Order Online

Is this your business?

Customize this page.

Claim This Business

Hours

Regular Hours

Tue - Thu:	5:00 pm - 9:30 pm
Fri - Sat:	5:00 pm - 10:00 pm

Mama Carolla's Old Italian Restaurant 1031 E 54th St, Indianapolis

If you're craving some Italian food in Indianapolis, then you've come to the right place! Mama Carolla's Old Italian Restaurant is known for being an outstanding Italian restaurant. They offer multiple other cuisines including Caterers, European, Mediterranean, Family Style, and Continental.

Interested in how much it may cost per person to eat at Mama Carolla's Old Italian Restaurant? The price per item at Mama Carolla's Old Italian Restaurant ranges from $4.00 to $25.00 per item.

In comparison to other Italian restaurants, Mama Carolla's Old Italian Restaurant is reasonably priced.

As an Italian restaurant, Mama Carolla's Old Italian Restaurant offers many common menu items you can find at other Italian restaurants, as well as some unique surprises. Here in Indianapolis, Mama Carolla's Old Italian Restaurant offers Entrees - Vitello (veal), Pasta - White Sauce, Entrees - Pesce, Pasta - Herbed Oil / Buttered Sauce, and Entrees - Pollo (chicken) and more. When it comes to some of the best menu items available, you can choose from:

Cousin Mary's
Veal Medallions
Tilapia
Misto Mare
Maiale (Pork) - Wow, Whata Pork Chop

If you would like to investigate further on pricing around all menu items, YP.com has provided you with the complete Indianapolis Mama Carolla's Old Italian Restaurant menu.

There are other nearby neighborhoods that Mama Carolla's Old Italian Restaurant in 46220 serves beside Indianapolis, and they include places like Carson Heights, The Village of Orchard Park, and Grand View Acres. If you want to see a complete list of all Italian restaurants in Indianapolis, we have you covered!

Looking for other top Italian restaurants in Indianapolis? More popular places to try are Amalfi Ristorante Italiano, Little Eataly, or Vito Provolone's Restaurant. If you don't mind traveling a bit, we can also recommend more great places to eat Italian food in nearby cities. Just give Mia's That Italian Place in Greenfield, Matteo's Ristorante Italiano in Noblesville or La Trattoria Italian Restaurant in Greenwood a try. Make sure to come back and leave a review at YP.com about what you liked and any recommendations for other users in our community!

After your meal at Mama Carolla's Old Italian Restaurant, don't forget that Indianapolis has a ton of amazing restaurants to try. Come back to YP.com and find tons of great restaurants in Indianapolis, take out restaurants in Indianapolis, or fast food restaurants in Indianapolis.

Don't forget to tell your friends how your experience went at Mama Carolla's Old Italian Restaurant in Indianapolis by leaving a review here at YP.com!

Places Near Indianapolis with Italian Restaurants

Broad Ripple (2 miles)
Broad Ripple Village (2 miles)
Carmel (14 miles)

More Types of Restaurants in Indianapolis

Asian Restaurants Spanish Restaurants Yogurt Mediterranean Restaurants Mongolian Restaurants Buffet Restaurants Continental Restaurants Peruvian Restaurants Family Style Restaurants Mexican Restaurants Kosher Restaurants Coffee Shops Tapas Home Cooking Restaurants Brazilian Restaurants Steak Houses Greek Restaurants French Restaurants Food Trucks Bagels Chicken Restaurants Donut Shops Chinese Restaurants Take Out Restaurants American Restaurants Irish Restaurants Middle Eastern Restaurants Soul Food Restaurants Dessert Restaurants Fine Dining Restaurants Pizza Internet Cafes Japanese Restaurants Korean Restaurants Cafeterias Delicatessens Latin American Restaurants Vietnamese Restaurants Sandwich Shops Indian Restaurants Barbecue Restaurants Fondue Restaurants Thai Restaurants Seafood Restaurants Italian Restaurants Caribbean Restaurants Fast Food Restaurants Cuban Restaurants Sushi Bars Vegetarian Restaurants Soda Fountain Shops Restaurant Menus Health Food Restaurants German Restaurants Tea Rooms African Restaurants

GalleryView all (10)

Add Photos

Reviews

Hi there!
Rate this business!

Click to Rate

(2)

KNKevin N.

03/28/2017

Overall

Atmosphere

Food

Service

Absolutely wonderful dining experience. Great atmosphere. The server we had was very helpful and personable. We live an hour away, but we will make the trip again just for this place. Reservations suggested on weekends.

Helpful(0)Flag

stephanieghrist

04/23/2012

Overall

best Italian I've ever had!

my husband and i ate here on our anniversary and it was awesome! get the cheese bread!!

Helpful(0)Flag